Does Chess Make You Smarter? What the Studies Actually Found

By Dawid Siedlarz · · 7 min read

Play Chess free →

Short answer: probably not, at least not in a way that shows up outside chess. The largest randomised trial, covering 4,009 pupils in England and 30 hours of lessons (Jerrim and colleagues, 2018), found an effect on maths of essentially zero a year later. An earlier meta-analysis of 24 studies (Sala and Gobet, 2016) reported a moderate gain, but almost none of those studies compared chess with another new activity. People with stronger cognitive abilities do tend to play somewhat better chess (r = 0.24), which isn't the same as chess giving them those abilities.

If you've ever been told chess will sharpen your mind, you've heard a claim almost no other board game gets. Parents sign children up for chess club in the hope that it will help with maths, schools add it to the timetable, and a good player is assumed to be clever at everything. The reasoning sounds airtight: chess takes calculation, memory and patience, so practising it should strengthen all three. Researchers have tested that idea many times, and the way the answer changes as the tests get stricter is the most interesting part.

The case for chess: a moderate effect in 24 studies

The strongest argument in favour comes from a meta-analysis by Giovanni Sala and Fernand Gobet (2016). They pooled 24 studies with 2,788 young people taught chess and 2,433 in comparison groups. The overall effect was g = 0.338, a bit stronger for maths (g = 0.382) than for reading (g = 0.248), and it grew with the length of the course. Studies with at least 25 hours of teaching reached g = 0.427.

Read alone, those numbers look like good news for your chess club. Sala and Gobet themselves were much more careful. No study in their review used what they call the ideal design, with random allocation, tests before and after, a group that does nothing new and a group that does some other new activity. That last group is the one that matters. Without it, a gain could come from the excitement of something new or from an enthusiastic instructor, and they noted that nearly no study had one. They concluded that chess "seems to exert a slight positive influence" and that there are still "serious doubts about the real effectiveness of its practice".

The biggest trial found nothing

You'd expect a big, careful test to shrink that number. It went further. The study built to settle the question was run in England by John Jerrim and colleagues (2018) and registered in advance. It involved 4,009 pupils in 100 primary schools, 50 randomly assigned to chess and 50 to carry on as normal. Pupils aged 9 to 10 received a 30-hour curriculum from trained tutors, more than the 25 hours the meta-analysis pointed to as the useful minimum. National test scores were measured at age 11, a year after the lessons ended.

The effect on maths was +0.001 standard deviations with all controls included, with a 95 percent confidence interval of roughly ±0.15. That range doesn't reach the 0.38 seen in the meta-analysis. Reading was -0.06 (from -0.21 to +0.09) and science -0.03 (from -0.13 to +0.08), neither distinguishable from zero. Children from low-income families also showed no benefit (+0.01, from -0.18 to +0.19), and the effect stayed under 0.05 at every level of achievement.

When chess gets a fair opponent

Sala and Gobet then ran the comparison their review had said was missing. In their two experiments published in 2017, Italian primary pupils learned chess while others learned a different game, so the novelty and attention were matched.

StudyWho took partCompared withResult
Sala and Gobet 2016 (meta-analysis)24 studies, 5,221 young peopleMostly no other new activityg = 0.338 overall
Jerrim et al. 2018 (England)4,009 pupils, age 9-10, 30 hoursSchools carrying on as normalMaths +0.001, no effect
Sala and Gobet 2017, experiment 1 (Italy)233 pupils, mean age 8.5, 25 hoursCheckers, and ordinary lessonsNo significant difference in maths (p = .679)
Sala and Gobet 2017, experiment 2 (Italy)52 pupils, mean age 9.3, 15 hoursGo, and ordinary lessonsChess no better than ordinary lessons (p = .487)

In the first experiment, pupils who played checkers ended up with an adjusted maths score of 1.75, the chess group 1.64 and the group with ordinary lessons 1.83, on a six-question test. The differences were not significant. The second experiment replaced part of the maths and science timetable with the games, and the chess group did no better than pupils who simply kept their normal lessons. Neither sample was randomised child by child and the second is tiny, so neither experiment settles it alone. The authors' verdict was still blunt: the effects, "if any", are modest when rigorously tested, and such courses "should not replace the traditional curriculum in mathematics".

This pattern has a name, far transfer: the hope that practising one thing improves something quite different. Sala and Gobet concluded that far transfer from chess is "very unlikely". It is the same result found for brain-training apps, where people get better at the trained game and not much else.

So why are chess players often clever?

The link is real, and it mostly seems to run through ability. A meta-analysis by Alexander Burgoyne and colleagues (2016) combined 19 studies and 1,779 people. Chess skill correlated with fluid reasoning (r = 0.24), acquired knowledge (0.22), short-term memory (0.25) and processing speed (0.24), an average of 0.24, or about 6 percent of the differences in skill. It was stronger for numerical ability (0.35) than for verbal (0.19) or visuospatial ability (0.13).

The link also shrank with experience. Fluid reasoning correlated 0.32 with chess skill in young players but 0.11 in adults, and 0.32 among unranked players against 0.14 among ranked ones. The authors concluded that cognitive ability contributes to chess skill, particularly in young players and at lower levels. This is a correlation, so on its own it can't rule out chess raising those abilities. The trials above didn't measure IQ directly, but they did look for a gain in maths, the ability most closely tied to chess skill, and found none. The simpler reading is that sharper thinkers find chess easier at the start.

Where the researchers still disagree

The English trial isn't the last word, and its critics have fair points. In a 2017 review, Sala, Foley and Gobet doubted the null result because the only test came a year after the lessons ended and because the maths test may have had a ceiling (mean score about 70 percent). They read the literature as showing maths gains "in the short term but not in the long term". One of those three authors worked for the charity that delivered the English programme, which is worth knowing when weighing that argument, and the trial itself was analysed by researchers at University College London.

Jerrim and his team also state their limits plainly. They tested academic outcomes only, so they can't say anything about confidence or other non-cognitive skills, and they can't generalise to other countries or to younger or older children. All four studies above are about children and school. They say nothing about adults or about ageing, which is a separate question that these trials didn't test.

What this means if you love chess or want your child to play

  • Teach maths with maths. Sala and Gobet's advice is that learning activities should be as close as possible to the skill you want. Replacing maths lessons with chess is the one choice the evidence argues against.
  • If you want chess to help with maths, make the link explicit. They suggest using the board to introduce a coordinate grid, or the king's moves to explain distance on a grid. A connection nobody points out may never be made.
  • Play it because it is a great game. Enjoyment is a real benefit, and the trial's authors say so themselves. You don't need a study to justify an hour of chess, and we'd be the last to ask you for one.

Where to play

Our Chess runs in your browser against the computer on three levels. Easy looks one move ahead and picks a random legal move about a third of the time. Medium looks two moves ahead and follows every capture through. Hard searches up to five moves ahead within two seconds. Dots show every legal move, and Ctrl or Cmd + Z takes one back. Trying a different idea in a position you just misjudged is practice at chess itself, and getting better at the thing you practise is the one kind of improvement nobody in this research disputes.

If you would rather play the game the Italian control group learned, try Checkers (with a rules guide), or Reversi for a game where the position can flip in one move.

Frequently asked questions

Does playing chess make you smarter?

The best evidence says probably not in any way that shows up outside chess. The largest randomised trial, with 4,009 pupils in England and 30 hours of lessons, found no effect on maths, reading or science test scores a year later. A 2016 meta-analysis did find a moderate gain, but almost none of its studies compared chess with another new activity.

Does chess improve maths?

A 2016 meta-analysis of 24 studies reported a gain of about g = 0.38 in maths, but the later and better-controlled studies did not confirm it. The English trial's estimate was essentially zero, with a 95 percent confidence interval of roughly plus or minus 0.15 standard deviations. Two Italian experiments also found no advantage over checkers or ordinary lessons.

Are chess players more intelligent?

On average they score somewhat higher on cognitive tests. A meta-analysis of 19 studies and 1,779 people found an average correlation of 0.24 between chess skill and cognitive abilities, which is about 6 percent of the variance. A correlation cannot show that chess caused the higher scores.

Should children learn chess at school?

It is a good game and children may enjoy it, but the research does not support using it as a replacement for maths lessons. Sala and Gobet wrote that such courses should not replace the traditional maths curriculum. The English trial measured only test scores, so it says nothing about confidence or enjoyment.

What is far transfer?

Far transfer means that practising one skill improves a quite different one, such as chess lessons raising maths marks. Near transfer is improvement in closely related tasks. Chess research is one of the main test cases for far transfer, and the better studies find little or none.